I’ve been lucky to have seen more than several major shifts in the IT World over more years than I may admit. In each of these shifts, control and management have been central components—challenges to success.

For me, it started

  • in college with computer courses;
  • in business, with computer operations and consulting;
  • in a position with a major insurance company.

It was all about internal control from systems design to programming and computer installation and training to major design and business growth—decades of designing and implementing operational solutions for consulting with the business world.

Oxford English Dictionary:

garbage in, garbage out (GIGO)

“used to express the idea that, in computing and other spheres, incorrect or poor quality input will always produce faulty output”

I might say it another way: “Good work creates good results.”

Not only for IT; it applies to all aspects of life.  

 Giving someone the wrong directions or the wrong address can mess up everyone’s day because of GIGO.  As we have become more and more sophisticated, the need to heed warnings of “garbage in, garbage out” has increased.  We are more sophisticated but also more complacent—relaxed in thinking that things work more easily now.  I don’t think that is the case.  What about you?

Nothing new really because, as this quote says: “an early reference to the idea is sometimes credited to 19th-century British mathematician and engineer Charles Babbage(*) in the 1820s”.   A more modern reference is “George Fuechsel, an IBM programmer and instructor, who is often credited with coining or popularizing the term in the early 1960s.”(**)

Actually, it can be fun to research development and evolution of the phrase.  The cold truth is that it is real, maybe more real today than ever before; paying attention to it might be a lifesaver for many of us.  I find one of the more annoying examples in the grocery store—you think the price on the shelf is the real price, maybe a deal at that, then at the register, after struggling with the computer or the employee, you discover you’re wrong.  Led down a wrong path by “garbage in, garbage out”.

I think one of the interesting things about GIGO is that the people doing GI often believe that what they are doing is good, correct, helpful.  The person giving the directions may be sure — from memory, of course, that it was correct.  Years and years ago, I was auditing internal control on a report process.  In the process, the far-right column total must equal the total of the last line of numbers— programmers had their orders: it must balance.  When they didn’t, there was a formula to make it so.

It was fixed, of course, and things went on charmingly.  Interesting that this kind of thing had been identified in programming for years as an example of GIGO, even in the literature.  We are talking years—it was sort of a joke but not a laughing matter.  Did the programmer believe s(he) was doing the right thing?  Yes, it was taken literally.

Over the years, it’s more and more important that the quality of data, information, ideas, spelling of all sorts is correct.  What can an extra zero do to a price tag?  (Well, $15 can become $150 and so on.)  The wrong digit on an address can find you miles from where you should be.  I was doing some research on a quote: where it came from and by whom.  The search engine came up with the right name but had referred to that particular playwright as a fictional character in a well-known TV show—not the case.  Now, this was not an unknown individual, they were amazingly well known.  How was it wrong?  Was it me?  Was it the software or was it AI information?  Maybe it was something else?

Obviously, with the current new system on the block, AI presents a major concern of humans: Will it take my job?  In each of the major shifts in IT over the years, this question rose up and, interestingly, in most phases, there was more need for humans than anyone thought.  Now, maybe this will not be the case in this phase but I believe the jury is still out on that.

Back in July 2022, 3 of my associates and I participated in one of my Always Creating Value® Podcasts to explore how we might, together, create ways to help maximize, for the good of all, the promise of technology.  The focus was to tap into a need for more humanity in the equation—solidifying that people matter.  We talked about many aspects and it all came down to hoping that humans will have more of a say in aspects of this IT/AI world than just technology.

Our panel included Marty Cooper (“father of the cell phone”), Lon Safko (inventor of the first computer to save a person’s life), David Cieslak (expert in the field of IT in the World of Public Accounting); Mark H Fowler (me, myself and I: with expertise in crisis management and systems development to create business growth).  All of us had been part of the life and evolution of computers and their importance in our businesses and personal realities.  Please see the link to the Podcast: https://estowemanagement.com/it-ai-experts-discuss/

Though humans are an integral part of how GIGO blossoms in our systems and day-to-day world, they are also the salvation.  Who is going to spot the gaffes and blunders?  There is better programming and there are also people who get caught in these errors and must find the way out or, hopefully, prevent those errors.

In all the IT systems we helped design for organizations, we took some extra time up front to help ensure success.  This is where people added additional value.  After the research and needs analysis — but before it was off to software development, we crafted both manual and existing software enhancements.  These were not major changes coming but they were changes that would allow everyone involved to feel closer and more comfortable with new applications.

Did it work?  It worked big time, because people were already compliant and knowledgeable with idiosyncrasies of the system.  The net result was a system that came on line more quickly with fewer mistakes and changes.  The people felt better about themselves because they could help new software be most effective.  It was a win/win and, from overall timing, it took less time to make it work.

An integral component of systems success was ultimate management of “garbage in, garbage out”.  Because we did it this way, there were fewer mistakes, higher quality data, better communication, more timely delivery.

For the future, systems management and people management may not look like it did in previous IT generations, but it will need to be there.  It could mean more management or less to maintain information/data quality and integrity.

As our panel’s focus was to tap into a need for more humanity in the equation, solidifying that people matter, maybe it will be a reduction of chaos that GIGO creates.  I hope something balances the need for technology and humans.  I hope you do as well.

I leave you with a reality that is both positive and concerning.  As AI evolves and People grow and develop, there is an additional Truth:  “we don’t know what we don’t know”; the same goes about digital processing: “it doesn’t know what it doesn’t know.”  Only together, with both human and digital, we will be able successfully to weather additional capabilities and not destroy ourselves.

Good luck to us all.  Thanks for listening.

* Charles Babbage was an English polymath.  A mathematician, philosopher, inventor and mechanical engineer, Babbage originated the concept of a digital programmable computer.  Babbage is considered by some to be “father of the computer”.  He is credited with inventing the first mechanical computer, the difference engine, that eventually led to more complex electronic designs, though all the essential ideas of modern computers are to be found in his analytical engine, programmed using a principle openly borrowed from the Jacquard loom.  As part of his computer work, he also designed the first computer printers.  He had a broad range of interests in addition to his work on computers, covered in his 1832 book Economy of Manufactures and Machinery.  His varied work in other fields has led him to be described as “pre-eminent” among the many polymaths of his century.

** Published in EBSCO: 2024 by Richard Sheposh

Google: “Garbage In, Garbage Out”

 

Mark H. Fowler, President Stowe Management CorporationABOUT MARK H. FOWLER

Mark H. Fowler, President of Stowe Management Corporation and Founder/Co-CEO of Revolutionary Conversations, LLC, is a business growth and business re-engineering expert, author and writer, business educator, public speaker and change leader. Mr. Fowler specializes in transitioning businesses from challenge to achievement to attain new levels of success: focused on enhancing revenues and profits, while instituting cultural and interactive processes that substantially increase collaboration and engagement. As a member of AICPA and California CPA Society, he has served in several leadership roles. He is a Co-Founder of the Rotary E-Club of World Peace.

A leader in the “business engagement” field for decades, he has developed systems and communication protocols, stressing importance of team empowerment and personal development. With his emphasis on engagement, he created and designed a conversation system called the S.H.A.R.E.™ Tools, which are the basis of the award-winning book Revolutionary Conversations: The Tools You Need for the Success You Want. The S.H.A.R.E.™ Tools are an essential ingredient for success in working with all forms of challenges and impediments, while always focusing on the value and well-being of all. Working with owners/executives/leaders/managers/team members in a revolutionary, transformational way to be on the same page in order to move forward together, he has aided their success with incredible achievements that were unattainable in their former reality.

Subscribe to our Podcast!

Join our podcast live! Receive our Newsletter. Benefit from Mark H. Fowler’s progressive insights for your success, you can subscribe for free and receive Mark’s valuable experience in Business Consulting, Crisis Management, Managing Growth & Profitability, Mergers & Acquisitions, Succession Planning, Systems & Operational Analysis and more.

Over the years, I have worked with many good corporate citizens, who know that many lives depend on the way they do business. In the process, not only have these businesses and organizations been more successful, but we have all had fun along the way.” –Mark H. Fowler

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.